Montana Governor Dodged Accountability After He Shot Yellowstone Research Lion Out Of Tree

Allegedly, the animal was not just any mountain lion, but a male wildcat with a GPS tracking collar around its neck, part of important ongoing wildlife research in Yellowstone National Park. The project, led by park biologist Dan Stahler, is intended to shed light on how the stealthy animals live, moving back and forth across the invisible boundary of America’s first national park.

One might think Gov. Gianforte, a proud outspoken big game hunter, would not hesitate to confirm or deny the incident occurred when contacted. One might think that in the name of accuracy, he and his press secretary, Brooke Stroyke, would openly answer questions to help insure that details of the incident were reported accurately.

This is not solely the real-life tale of a prominent public official who killed a five-year-old animal, Cougar M220, that lived much of its life in Yellowstone and died after wandering 10 miles north of it; it is also a story, observers say, of obfuscation by Gianforte and his staff in being willing to tell the truth when asked, ostensibly because the details might be embarrassing. It raises questions, too, about what constitutes real fair chase in the hunting of iconic animals.

° ° ° °

For purposes of what appears here in Mountain Journal, this also involves the decision to not impetuously tell a story based on hearsay and rumor, but an attempt to try to get confirmation that the alleged incident actually happened. Related is the irony that public officials like Gov. Gianforte who has shown his disdain for so-called “liberal media,” and who has claimed the media often gets stories wrong, would not, when pressed, confirm or deny facts.

A reporter for The Washington Post wrote a story published on March 1, two months after the incident occurred, in which Stroyke was forced to acknowledge that Gianforte had killed the cougar on Monday, Dec. 28, 2021. The attempt to get corroboration had, for Mountain Journal, been ongoing for several weeks with Stroyke refusing to respond to media inquiries.

Montana Gov. Greg Gianforte

Mountain Journal first contacted Stroyke by email at 3:50 pm on Jan. 4, 2022 with the request for a phone call.  She responded at 4:32 pm on that same day with a note, “What can I help you with?”

A few minutes later, this journalist wrote back: “Hi Brooke, I am trying to confirm/factcheck if Gov. Gianforte had a successful mountain lion hunt up Tom Miner Basin on Dec. 28, who his guide was, where the hunt took place and how the hunt unfolded. Some information was passed along by an outfitter and I like to be accurate. Can you please confirm or correct the info and provide any other details?”

The next morning, on Jan. 5, Stroyke responded, “Looking into this.”

A week later, she was contacted by email again but Mountain Journal received no reply.  Another phone message was left. Several additional weeks passed and another email was sent—still nothing on Feb. 15.

Mountain Journal believes it is better to be second and accurate than first and risk being in error. While the incident is one of great public interest, and while several people in Paradise Valley who knew about the incident pressed us to publish something, we refrained because we could not get confirmation from anyone who was part of the cougar hunt.

According to state law, the identities of hunters who kill cougars, wolves and other animals are not, and cannot, be disclosed by state fish and wildlife officials to the public. The law is intended, in part, to protect hunters and trappers from being harassed by animal rights activists. The state keeps an ongoing tally of both wolves and cougars killed during sport seasons in various parts of the state but it does not divulge exact locations, nor the identities of outfitters and guides who might be chaperoning clients.

Not long after the tip arrived from a caller who asked to remain anonymous, and a few snippets of information were posted on social media, Mountain Journal chose not to publicize or circulate information that could not be immediately verified. 

Here is how the fact-checking worked. Contact was made with officials in the district office of the U.S. Forest Service to obtain a list of hunting guides permitted to pursue cougars with hounds in the Gallatin Range in areas of Tom Miner Basin and Rock Creek. Contact was made with Yellowstone National Park to try to confirm that a radio-collared cougar had been killed north of the park but park officials said they were unable to comment.

Mountain Journal also left a phone message and sent an email to hunting outfitter Matt Lumley, who has served as vice president of the National Trappers Association to get confirmation and a comment. Lumley had guided Gianforte in 2021 when he killed a radio-collared black wolf, known as Wolf 1155, that was part of an ongoing wolf research project in Yellowstone. Lumley also is a ranch manager at Point of Rocks Ranch where Gov. Gianforte had shot the wolf in February 2021.

The ranch is owned by Robert E. Smith, an executive with conservative Sinclair Broadcast Group. He reportedly is a good friend of the governor’s and has been a contributor to Gianforte’s run for public office.

The leaked information given to Mountain Journal was based, at least in part, on conversations overheard at a local saloon and suggested that Lumley was with Gianforte when he killed the mountain lion. Lumley did not respond to Mountain Journal’s request for a chat. 

On four different occasions, the first being within days of the alleged cougar killing, Mountain Journal reached out to Ms. Stroyke. The first reply received was cordial. The second said that she would look into it. The third and fourth inquiries went unanswered. 

Without being able to get confirmation from the governor, his guide or another eyewitness, evidence that Gianforte had killed the cougar would have been based on hearsay which runs counter to allowable content in Mountain Journal.

In the meantime, Mountain Journal did thorough fact-checking confirming that a cougar, part of ongoing Yellowstone wildlife research, was killed in the area Gianforte was purported to be—in the Rock Creek drainage on the Custer Gallatin National Forest.  

Another tip suggested that Lumley had pursued the cougar which tried to flee by climbing a tree, then contacted Gianforte and told him that the cat could likely be held for three hours but the governor needed to get to Rock Creek as fast as possible if he wanted to shoot it. The person did not know where the governor was when he received the call, allegedly from Lumley, but said Gianforte flew his private airplane to Mission Field airport in Livingston, Montana and then drove south to where the cougar was treed.

That assertion could not be proved, as an online flight log shows no record of Gianforte’s private plane landing in Livingston in late December 2021.

Again, Mountain Journal sought to corroborate all information with both the governor and Lumley. After The Washington Post learned of the incident and moved to publish a story on March 1, Stroyke was forced to hastily craft a statement.  

According to the Post, the statement written by Stroyke read: 

“The governor and friends tracked the lion on public lands. As the group got closer to the lion, members of the group, who have a hound training license, used four hounds to tree the lion once the track was discovered in a creek bottom on public land.” After Gianforte shot the male radio-collared lion, he put his lion hunting tag on it, Stroyke wrote. “He immediately called to report the legal harvest and then the [Montana Fish, Wildlife and Parks] game warden. In Livingston, the governor met the game warden who tagged the lion and took the collar.”

The Post story reads: “The mountain lion hunt, which has not been previously reported, occurred on Dec. 28 on a swath of U.S. Forest Service land southwest of Emigrant, Mont., according to residents familiar with the episode who spoke on the condition of anonymity to preserve relationships in the community.”

Mountain Journal does not base stories on unnamed sources who speak “on the condition of anonymity to preserve relationships in the community.” 

[Note: this added on March 3: The Daily Montanan newspaper is reporting that Stroyke claims The Washington Post story, based on unnamed sources, is wrong, that Gianforte participated in every aspect of the cougar hunt and did not show up to shoot it only after the cat had been treed. Of course, Stroyke could have made this clear two months ago when Mountain Journal first contacted her to confirm or deny information circulating in Paradise Valley but she would not respond].

What Gianforte did in killing the cougar is legal. While he committed a minor offense in killing the wolf months earlier by failing to undergo a wolf-trapping certification class beforehand, it wasn’t a big deal.

Here are two questions, however, related to Gianforte’s killing of both the cougar and the wolf in 2021. 

We don’t know how exactly Gianforte killed the wolf in the trap or the cougar in the tree. The best speculation is to assume he shot both animals. However, this raises questions of whether it is considered ethical for a trophy hunter to kill an animal that is unable to flee. Does it violate “fair chase” principles enshrined by the Boone & Crockett Club?

° ° ° °

E. Donnal Thomas Jr. of Lewistown, Montana is a retired board certified physician, nationally respected outdoor writer, lifelong hunter and houndsman who has been running dogs in pursuit of cougars since the 1980s. 

Thomas, by his own estimation, has treed between 80 and 90 cougars over the years. Personally, he has only shot two, he said. “Catch and release lion hunting is a lot of fun,” he added. He also has been contracted by ranchers to help them lethally remove cougars that chronically prey on domestic cattle and sheep. 

Thomas said that although it’s legal in Montana to hold a cat in a tree for hours, he said that “in terms of ethics, I believe doing that is grossly unethical.”

The Boone & Crockett Club describes fair chase this way: “Fair Chase, as defined by the Boone and Crockett Club, is the ethical, sportsmanlike, and lawful pursuit and taking of any free-ranging wild game animal in a manner that does not give the hunter an improper or unfair advantage over the game animals.” It goes on, “Fair chase is what separates hunting from simply killing or shooting. It demands restraint and self-reliance, aligns with North American wildlife laws, and is in service to conservation."

When asked to comment on Gianforte shooting a wolf in a trap in early 2021 and then, seven months later, shooting a mountain lion out of a tree, unable to escape, Thomas said, “If those are the facts, it suggests to me that you are dealing with an unethical party. I would draw the distinction that it’s the difference between a hunter and shooter. He didn’t hunt the lion and he didn’t have to hike for six hours to reach it. It sounds as if all he did was walk to the bottom of the tree, pull the trigger and kill it.”

Outrage over Gianforte’s killing of the cougar, coupled with him shooting a wolf from Yellowstone caught in a trap and his promotion of liberal hunting and trapping of wolves outside the park, is growing nationally. Thomas claims these two examples of trophy hunting involving a high-profile public official actually give hunting a bad image, not matter how Gianforte tries to spin it.

On March, 2, the Center for Biological Diversity issued a statement.  “Shooting this collared cat was another sad sign of Gianforte’s misguided contempt for carnivores,” said Michael Robinson of the Center for Biological Diversity. “Yellowstone’s cougars and wolves are vital to the natural balance in the world’s first national park, and GPS-collared animals help scientists understand these fascinating animals. The governor’s cruel killing spree around Yellowstone sets back research and illustrates why states dominated by the ruthless livestock industry can’t be trusted to oversee rare wildlife.”

The revelation comes on the heels of a hunting season in which one of every five wolves in Yellowstone was killed this year when they wandered outside the national park into Montana and Wyoming. A controversial, aggressive hunting and trapping season in Montana approved by the state legislature and enacted by the Montana Fish and Wildlife Commission resulted in 82 wolves killed in a region of southwest Montana abutting Yellowstone.

The reasoning advanced by Gianforte and his allies in the state legislature is that wolves are decimating big game herds and have imposed huge losses on the livestock industry, both of which are not supported by facts. 

Along the park’s northern border, so many members of the Phantom Lake Pack, including pups of the year, were shot or trapped so that the pack no longer exists. Some 25 Yellowstone wolves, part of the most visible and beloved group of wolves in the world, were killed. in Montana and Wyoming; some 19 of those were killed by hunters and trappers north of Yellowstone from September 2021 to late February 2022, compared to an allowable quota of just two along the park border in Montana in 2021.

° ° ° °

Not long ago, former Montana Supreme Court Justice James C. Nelson, now retired, wrote an essay in which he called out state government in Montana for stonewalling in its release of information that the public has a right to know. 

He did not mention the Gianforte Administration by name. Gianforte has established a reputation for being hostile to the media. Not only did he assault a national reporter after he became irritated with the journalist’s question—and was assigned to complete 40 hours of community service and 20 hours of anger management classes—but a member of his staff lied in denying the incident occurred. Only after a recording of the incident surfaced did Gianforte, then a Congressional candidate, and his staff admit it happened.

In the case of Gianforte killing the cougar, he is not a regular citizen but rather, as governor, a public figure and therefore is accountable to the public that elected him. The fact that a governor from a Western state killed a cougar that was part of a research effort in nearby Yellowstone and it involved the controversial practice of holding the public animal in a tree on a national forest for hours before he could arrive to shoot it is news.

His spokeswoman, Stroyke, is, by law, a civil servant political appointee, whose job as press secretary is to be forthcoming with the media. She is a public, not private, employee and answerable not to the governor but to the public which pays her salary.

In Justice Nelson’s piece, he wrote: “All of these practices frustrate the right to know and the right of speech, expression and the press.  All of these deprive We the People of fundamental rights that are constitutionally guaranteed ours to exercise and enjoy and which state actors are constitutionally not permitted to deprive, impair or to legislate away. All of these shenanigans are antithetical to transparent government.”

The public, Nelson wrote, has a right to know. “Worse, while unacceptable in their own right, these and other practices like these perpetrated by government employees, officials and actors represent an even greater evil. These people disrespect and disregard our Constitution and We the People—in whom all political power is vested and from whom the power of governance is derived.”

Below is email sent to Gianforte's press secretary Brooke Stroyke on Jan. 4, 2022: