Back to StoriesTiny Trouble in Microplastics
December 13, 2024
Tiny Trouble in MicroplasticsOutdoor and camping gear’s push to stay light and dry leaves it exposed to big health risks
A delaminating water-resistant coating on a rain jacket can shed microparticles of toxic perfluorochemicals, or PFCs, into the environment. Recent studies show many of these “forever chemicals” used to make camping gear dry, nonstick or lightweight can cause cancer and other hormone-related diseases in humans. Photo by Robert Chaney
by
Robert Chaney
The “leave no trace” ethos for
backcountry recreation has moved to the molecular level as research and
regulation target many of the chemicals that make camping gear waterproof, non-stick
and durable.
The changes have quietly appeared
on discount racks in sporting goods stores, where last year’s raincoats and
cookware show steep price cuts. And the trouble comes in many ways: from perfluorochemical
“forever chemicals,” or PFCs, treating sleeping bag down
feathers, to microplastic bits getting into fish and bird bloodstreams, to
flame retardants in black plastic spatulas and food containers.
According to the Montana Department
of Environmental Quality’s PFAS 2024 Progress Report, state researchers have been
examining both drinking water sources and fish tissue samples for chemical
contamination. Among other state findings, the researchers detected PFC traces
in four creek water samples around Bozeman.
“Studies that have occurred suggest that exposure to
certain PFAS may lead to health problems including changes in the liver,
immunological effects, increased cholesterol levels, cardiovascular effects, reproductive
effects in women, developmental effects in infants and children, and an
increased risk of kidney and testicular cancer,” according to Montana DEQ.
The problem extends to that most
cherished bit of outdoor gear: raincoats. They typically depended on
perfluoroalkyl and polyfluoroalkyl treatments. Those fluorinated carbon
chemicals produce durable, heat-stable fabrics that repel water and oils.
“Water repellency is talked about a lot, but the health issues have never been brought up by any of our customers.” – Reid Beck, owner, Genesis Gear
Ironically, much of the problem
stems from efforts to be light on the land. For example, the brominated flame
retardants now raising warnings on black plastic cooking utensils appear to come from recycled
electronics casings.
Another common source is the nonstick coatings on cookware that kept
lightweight pans from scorching the dehydrated scrambled eggs.
In one outdoor gear store example,
a frying pan’s label crowed “Of course our premium 304 (18/8) stainless steel
construction is still non-reactive, free of BPA, PFOA and Phthalates. What
could be better than that?” (BPA, a bisphenol compound, and PFOA, a type of PFC,
make water bottles durable and cookware nonstick.)
But just below that boast is a
warning label that notes: “The following chemicals: Fluorpolymer (PFAS), Iron,
Chromium, Nickel, Molybdenum on the designated list have been intentionally
added to this cookware’s non-stick surface,” with a QR code to California state
hazardous materials regulations.
Some gear makers have marketed new products emphasizing their move away from “forever chemical” use. Photo by Robert Chaney
PFCs can contaminate food,
especially when heated during cooking. They also enter the human body through
microparticles: flakes, fibers or films of treated fabrics or plastic
containers that chip away from gear during use and cycle back through the food
chain.
While chemical contamination issues
have been around for years, the topic drew new attention through several
developments in 2024. In September, attorneys representing residents of Elkton,
Maryland, announced plans to sue Gore, maker of Gore-Tex fabric, over
allegations the company has been contaminating drinking water supplies with PFC
chemicals from its facilities across the border in Delaware. Gore responded to questions from WHYY
Radio, stating “[The
allegations] do not accurately reflect our strong legacy of taking proactive
steps to process [PFC chemicals] responsibly, striving always to minimize any
potential environmental impact from our operations.” The attorneys alleged they
could document clusters of cancer and other disease cases in residents near the
plant stemming from PFC exposure.
The lawsuit announcement came about
five months after the Environmental Protection Agency released new rules designating two PFC chemicals often used in cookware, carpets
and firefighting foam as hazardous substances. The rules are intended to speed
up remediation of toxic deposits of the chemicals in public drinking water
supplies as well as require industries and users responsible for the
contamination to pay for the removal.
Among other state DEQ findings, researchers detected PFC traces in four creek water samples around Bozeman.
Backcountry users bear some direct
responsibility as well. In 2019, the nonprofit climate advocacy group Environment
Montana released its Microplastic in Montana study of water samples from 50
rivers across the state, in part prompting Bozeman voters last month to approve
a ban of single-use plastics beginning in May 2025. Two-thirds
of the waterway sites in the study turned up one or more types of microplastic,
such as synthetic fiber residue from fishing line and bailing twine, film from
plastic bags and fragments of rigid plastic from food containers.
Sites included the Yellowstone
River’s Yankee Jim Canyon and Grey Owl Fishing Access Site; the Boulder River Big
Rock FAS; the Madison River at Ennis and the Damselfly FAS between Norris and
Bozeman; the Beavertail River at Dillon; and at Three Forks, where the Madison,
Jefferson and Gallatin rivers coalesce to form the Missouri River.
Click here to view an interactive version of the map below.
Environment Montana in 2019 tested 50 river access sites in the state. "Most of them had plastic in the water," they said.
While health concerns about PFCs
have earned lots of national attention this year, the topic remains
touchy in the outdoor recreation community. Four stores contacted for this
article declined to answer interview questions about customer trends or
reactions to the national health warnings about PFAS and plastics exposure. Others
observed that the desire for lightweight, practical and water-resistant gear in
the backcountry may be an acceptable trade-off in a pastime that involves plenty
of other risks to life and limb.
“I’m never asked about it,” said
Reid Beck, owner of Genesis Gear, a camping equipment rental business in
Bozeman. “Water repellency is talked about a lot, but the health issues have
never been brought up by any of our customers.”
Nevertheless, parts of the industry
have responded. Gear makers such as Helly Hansen and Patagonia have announced plans to make their
water-repellant finishes PFC-free. Cookware makers have introduced ceramic
coatings to replace old Teflon non-stick surfaces. One has even introduced a
line of cast-iron pans aimed at the more burley backpacking set.
__________________________________________________________________________________________________
Mountain Journal is a nonprofit, public-interest journalism organization dedicated to covering the wildlife and wild lands of Greater Yellowstone. We take pride in our work, yet to keep bold, independent journalism free, we need your support. Please donate here. Thank you.
Related Stories
August 29, 2024
Restoring Wildlife Connectivity Across the High Divide
Throughout
the High Divide, century-old fencing is coming down to improve migration
corridors for pronghorn, elk and other wildlife.
April 8, 2024
Can a Groundwater Recharge Program Save Teton Valley's Farmers?
In Teton Valley,
Idaho, where water is as precious as its native trout, irrigators and
environmental groups have teamed up to recharge the...
January 2, 2024
50 Years: How the Endangered Species Act Influenced Greater Yellowstone
To celebrate the 50th anniversary of the
Endangered Species Act, Mountain Journal looks at the landmark legislation’s
impact on some of Greater Yellowstone’s...